An Open Letter to the American Jewish Leaders Who Participated in a May 31st Working Dinner with President George W. Bush
Justice4JP Release - June 21, 2001 - 2 pages
Please reprint; please recirculate
Dear Jewish Leaders: Abraham Foxman, Jack Rosen, Max Fisher, Mel Sembler, Ronald Lauder, Malcolm Hoenlein, Mayer Mitchell, Lonny Kaplan, Stephen Solender, Richard Heideman, Bob Goodkind, and Bonnie Lipton, who met with President George W. Bush on May 31, 2001 at the White House:
How is it that in 16 years and 4 successive administrations, Jonathan Pollard has never been on the official agenda of Jewish leaders when you meet with the President to discuss Jewish concerns?
JONATHAN POLLARD is a Jew who spied for Israel. He broke the law when he warned Israel that Saddam Hussein was preparing unconventional weapons of war to scorch the Jewish State. Jonathan is the only person in the history of the United States to receive a for spying for an ally.
In similar cases, such as that of non-Jew U.S. Navy Lcdr. who spied for Saudi Arabia, sentences are usually fairly light, 2 to 4 years being the median. Schwartz confessed to and was indicted for the same offense as Jonathan. In deference to the Saudi ally, a deal was worked out whereby Schwartz was punished only by loss of his job, his pension and his Navy rank.
POLLARD GOT LIFE. SCHWARTZ GOT NO JAIL TIME.
By way of comparison, those who spied for
ENEMIES of the United States and/or committed far more serious crimes than Jonathan Pollard, include:
MICHAEL WALKER, part of the infamous
WALKER SPY RING, was arrested in 1985, the same year as Jonathan Pollard. The spy ring he belonged to operated for 17 years, selling sensitive US military secrets to the Soviet Union, causing what authorities described as extensive damage to national security. He was sentenced to 25 years.
WALKER IS A FREE MAN TODAY.
CLAYTON LONETREE, a marine sergeant guarding the US Embassy in Moscow, spied for the KGB and was sentenced in 1987 to 30 years. His sentence was reduced 3 times.
LONETREE IS A FREE MAN TODAY.
RICHARD MILLER is the first FBI agent ever tried for espionage. He turned over secrets, including a counter-intelligence manual, to the Soviets. He was sentenced to 20 years.
MILLER IS A FREE MAN TODAY.
ABDELKADER HELMY, a missile researcher, was sentenced in 1989 for selling technology related to the Condor Missile project to Egypt which found its way to Iraq. He got 48 months and served considerably less.
HELMY IS A FREE MAN TODAY.
SAMUEL MORISON, a Navy analyst, removed scores of confidential material, including photos he
sold that were printed in Jane's Defense Weekly. The Photos were classified SCI; exposing such sensitive material carries a mandatory life sentence. The grandson of an illustrious Navy Historian, his family ties are the only way to explain why in 1985 he was sentenced to only 2 years, and served only 3 months. What is more, in spite of extreme opposition by the CIA to clemency, Morison received a full pardon from former President Clinton in January 2001.
MORISON IS A FREE MAN TODAY.
ONLY JONATHAN POLLARD REMAINS IN PRISON
IN HIS 16th YEAR OF A LIFE SENTENCE
Seven years in solitary confinement and 16 years of the harshest treatment that the American penal system can mete out have virtually destroyed Jonathan's immune system. His health has deteriorated, putting his life in peril.
The Jewish leadership has repeatedly demonstrated outstanding lobbying skills on those issues that it chooses to espouse. For example, the Jewish leadership and the Government of Israel recently succeeded in obtaining a pardon for
Marc Rich, a billionaire criminal fugitive from the law. The Jewish leaders lobbied more convincingly for Rich - who was not in prison nor in mortal danger - than they ever have for Jonathan Pollard, who stares Death in the face every day (G-d forbid) and dares not blink.
The deep involvement of the American Jewish leadership and the Government of Israel in securing a pardon for Rich, is a source of great embarrassment and shame for the Jewish community. In spite of the scandal surrounding the Rich pardon, both Israel and the Jewish community have ignored virtually every opportunity since then to demonstrate an equal concern for Jonathan Pollard.
Even Jonathan's new legal case - which documents a travesty of justice that has gone unchallenged for the last 16 years- has not prompted any sense of urgency on the part of Jewish leaders to see this case finally resolved.
This was the second White House meeting that you as Jewish leaders have had with President Bush since his inauguration. Both meetings were reported as "magical" and "enchanting" events where a "broad range of issues of concern to the Jewish Community and Israel" were discussed. The fate of Jonathan Pollard, an American Jew, dangerously ill and serving a grossly disproportionate sentence for his activities on behalf of Israel, was not one of them.
How is it that you, the Jewish leaders, have signed letters to the President calling for Jonathan's release, and yet you consistently fail to express that concern in face to face meetings?
How is it that in front of Jewish audiences, you claim to care so much about Jonathan, yet when you are facing the one man in the world who can sign a document to free him, you are struck dumb?
As a nation, and as a vibrant American community, all Jews feel deeply shamed by your silence. Your unwillingness to advocate openly and effectively to free Jonathan Pollard - after 16 years of this ordeal - demeans us as a people. Jewish history watches. Jonathan Pollard waits. How can you abandon him this way?
Mrs. Jonathan Pollard
WHO THEY ARE:
Abraham Foxman, director of the ADL
Jack Rosen, president of the American Jewish Congress
Max Fisher and
Mel Sembler, honorary chairmen of the Republican Jewish Coalition
Ronald Lauder, chairman, and
Malcolm Hoenlein, executive vice chairman of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations
Mayer Mitchell and
Lonny Kaplan, former presidents of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee
Stephen Solender, president of the United Jewish Communities
Richard Heideman, president of B'nai B'rith International
Bob Goodkind, chairman of the board of governors of the American Jewish Committee
Bonnie Lipton, president of Hadassah - The Women's Zionist Organization of America